Homemade yogurt VS store yogurt?

Effect on Health

When it comes to comparing homemade yogurt and store-bought yogurt, one important aspect to consider is their effect on health.

Homemade yogurt offers several advantages in terms of overall well-being. Firstly, the process of making homemade yogurt allows you to have full control over the ingredients used.

This means that you can choose high-quality milk and live cultures, ensuring that your yogurt contains no artificial additives or preservatives. By eliminating these undesirable elements, homemade yogurt becomes a healthier option for those concerned about their dietary choices.

Furthermore, homemade yogurt allows you to customize your fermentation time according to your individual preferences. The longer the fermentation period, the higher the probiotic content in the final product.

Probiotics are beneficial bacteria that promote gut health and boost digestion. With store-bought yogurts, you may not have control over how long they were fermented or how many viable live cultures they contain due to extended shelf life requirements.

These factors can directly impact the potency of probiotics present in store yogurts compared to their homemade counterparts. In addition to controlling ingredient quality and probiotic content, another health benefit of homemade yogurt is that it gives you more freedom to avoid potential allergens or intolerances.

Many people have specific dietary restrictions or sensitivities, such as lactose intolerance or allergies to certain additives commonly found in commercial yogurts. When making your own yogurt at home, you can select alternative milk options like coconut milk or almond milk for those who need non-dairy alternatives while still enjoying the same creamy texture and tangy taste of traditional yogurt.

Overall, when considering the effect on health between homemade and store-bought yogurts, opting for homemade provides greater control over ingredients and fermentation time while avoiding potential allergens or intolerances commonly found in commercial products. By choosing homemade yogurt as part of a balanced diet, individuals have a great opportunity to enhance their overall well-being through improved ingredient quality and increased probiotic content.


When comparing homemade yogurt to store-bought yogurt, one of the most significant differences lies in the ingredients used in each. Homemade yogurt typically requires just two main ingredients: milk and a starter culture containing live bacteria. But if you are using a probiotic yogurt maker, you do not need to worry about starter culture. Our yogurt maker has trillions of probiotics. So, creating yogurt is no a lot easier! Check It Out

The milk can be chosen based on personal preference, ranging from whole milk to low-fat or non-fat options. Furthermore, individuals can opt for organic or grass-fed milk, ensuring that their homemade yogurt is free from hormones or antibiotics often found in commercially produced dairy products.

On the other hand, store-bought yogurts often contain a range of additional ingredients that may not be present in homemade versions. These additives include preservatives, artificial flavors, sweeteners, stabilizers, and thickeners like gelatin or pectin.

While these additives help enhance taste and prolong shelf life, they may have potential health implications for some individuals with sensitivities or dietary restrictions. It is worth noting that some store-bought yogurts do offer natural and organic options without additives.

However, these products tend to be more expensive compared to conventional varieties. By making yogurt at home, individuals have complete control over the quality of ingredients used and can customize it to suit their preferences and dietary needs.

Flavor and Taste

When it comes to flavor and taste, homemade yogurt and store-bought yogurt offer distinct experiences.

Homemade yogurt often possesses a rich, creamy flavor that can be customized according to personal preferences. This is mainly because the process of making homemade yogurt allows for greater control over the ingredients used and the fermentation time.

By using high-quality milk, such as organic or grass-fed, one can enhance the flavor profile of homemade yogurt significantly. Furthermore, homemade yogurt offers a diversity of options when it comes to flavoring.

During the fermentation process, various ingredients like fruits, honey, vanilla extract, or even spices can be added to infuse different flavors into the final product. This allows individuals to experiment with different combinations and create unique taste sensations suited to their preferences.

On the other hand, store-bought yogurts usually come in a wide range of pre-flavored options that cater to different tastes. These options often include popular flavors like strawberry, blueberry, vanilla, or even exotic choices such as coconut or key lime pie.

While these flavored yogurts provide convenience and diversity in taste selection, some may contain artificial additives like sweeteners or preservatives that are not present in homemade versions. In terms of overall taste quality and intensity of flavors though, many argue that homemade yogurts have an edge over store-bought varieties due to their fresh ingredients and customizable nature.

The natural tanginess present in homemade yogurt can also vary depending on factors such as incubation temperatures and duration. Ultimately though subjective, those who appreciate subtle nuances in flavor profiles may find pleasure in creating their own unique blends with homemade yogurt while others who prefer convenience may opt for a variety of ready-made flavors available at grocery stores


Texture plays a crucial role in our overall experience of consuming yogurt, as it contributes to both the sensory pleasure and the perceived quality of the product. When comparing homemade yogurt to store-bought options, there are notable differences in texture that can significantly impact our preferences. Homemade yogurt often has a smoother and creamier texture compared to store-bought varieties.

This can be attributed to the absence of thickeners and stabilizers commonly found in commercial yogurts. The gentle fermentation process used in homemade yogurt allows for a delicate curd formation, resulting in a velvety consistency.

The lack of additives also means that homemade yogurt tends to have a more natural texture, allowing the flavors to shine through without any artificial aftertaste. On the other hand, store-bought yogurts often possess a firmer and thicker texture due to the addition of stabilizers like pectin or gelatin.

These ingredients help create a consistent and uniform texture, ensuring that every spoonful feels somewhat identical. While this may appeal to those who prefer a denser mouthfeel, some individuals find these added thickeners less appealing as they can give off a slightly gummy or slimy sensation.

When it comes to exploring different textures within the realm of homemade yogurt, there is room for experimentation and personalization. The length of fermentation time can directly influence the final consistency of homemade yogurt.

Longer fermentation periods generally result in firmer textures while shorter periods yield looser and more runny textures. Additionally, straining homemade yogurt through cheesecloth or muslin can produce variations such as Greek-style or strained yogurts with an even thicker consistency.

Ultimately, one's preference for texture depends on individual taste buds and desired culinary application. Whether you enjoy the silkiness of homemade yogurt or prefer the firmness found in commercially-produced options, understanding how different factors contribute to texture allows you to make an informed choice when selecting your preferred type of yogurt.


Probiotics play a crucial role in promoting a healthy gut. They are live bacteria and yeasts that are beneficial for our digestive system.

Both homemade yogurt and store-bought yogurt can contain probiotics, but the type and quantity may differ. Homemade yogurt is often made using bacterial cultures like Lactobacillus bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus, which are known for their probiotic properties.

These strains of bacteria help to break down lactose, improve digestion, and enhance nutrient absorption in the gut. Additionally, homemade yogurt allows you to have control over the fermentation process, ensuring that the beneficial bacteria remain alive and active.

On the other hand, store-bought yogurts generally undergo an intense pasteurization process to extend their shelf life. While this helps maintain the freshness of the product for a longer period, it also kills most of the natural bacteria present in it.

To compensate for this loss, some manufacturers add specific strains of live cultures back into their yogurts after pasteurization. However, it's essential to note that these added probiotics might not be as diverse or as abundant as those found in homemade yogurt.

When comparing homemade yogurt with store-bought ones in terms of probiotic content, it's important to consider factors such as storage conditions and expiration dates. Homemade yogurt tends to have a shorter shelf life due to its fresher nature and lack of preservatives compared to commercial options.

Thus, consuming homemade yogurt at its peak freshness maximizes its probiotic benefits. While both homemade yogurt and store-bought yogurts can provide probiotics that promote a healthy gut microbiome, there are differences in terms of variety and quantity.

Homemade yogurt offers more control over the fermentation process and allows you to incorporate diverse bacterial strains without compromising their viability. Thus, if maximizing your intake of live cultures is your primary concern when seeking out probiotic-rich foods like yogurt, homemade options may be the preferable choice.


When it comes to the cost comparison between homemade yogurt and store-bought yogurt, there are a few factors to consider.

While making your own yogurt may seem like a cheaper alternative at first glance, it is important to delve deeper into the numbers and evaluate the long-term expenses. Initially, making homemade yogurt requires an investment in a good quality yogurt maker or other equipment such as a Instant Pot or sous vide machine.

These appliances can range in price from $30 to $200 or more, depending on the brand and features. However, once you have acquired these tools, they can be used repeatedly for making batches of yogurt, thereby reducing the cost per serving over time.

Additionally, the ingredients required for homemade yogurt include milk and a starter culture or plain store-bought yogurt for inoculation. The cost of milk will vary depending on whether you choose organic or traditional options.

On average, a gallon of milk can range from $3 to $5. The starter culture or plain yogurt usually costs around $2 to $4 per container.

However, it is worth noting that once you've made your own batch of homemade yogurt, you can save some as a starter culture for future batches rather than purchasing it again. On the other hand, store-bought yogurts come in various sizes and brands with differing price points.

Generally speaking though, individual servings of store-bought yogurts tend to be more expensive per ounce compared to making your own at home. This is due in part to production costs incurred by manufacturers that are passed on to consumers.

When considering cost savings over time with homemade yogurt versus store-bought options, it becomes evident that while there may be an initial investment in equipment and ingredients for DIY enthusiasts, the long-term benefits outweigh these initial expenses. Not only are you able to control ingredient quality and flavor when making your own yogurt but also save money by avoiding frequent purchases of pre-packaged yogurts.


When it comes to the great yogurt debate - homemade versus store-bought - there are several factors to consider. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, but ultimately, it boils down to personal preference and priorities.

From a health perspective, homemade yogurt has the upper hand. By controlling the ingredients and fermentation process, you can ensure that your yogurt is free from additives, preservatives, and excessive sugars.

This not only promotes a healthier lifestyle but also allows you to tailor the yogurt to your specific dietary needs or preferences. On the other hand, store-bought yogurts may offer convenience but often contain artificial flavors and sweeteners that can be detrimental to overall health if consumed in excess.

When it comes to flavor and taste, homemade yogurt shines through again. The opportunity to experiment with various fruits, nuts, spices or even adding honey or maple syrup allows for endless possibilities in creating a personalized flavor profile that satisfies your taste buds.

In contrast, store-bought yogurts may offer a wide range of flavors but can sometimes lack the freshness and authenticity found in homemade versions. Texture plays a significant role in determining one's satisfaction with yogurt.

Homemade yogurt tends to have a creamier consistency because of its higher milk fat content or straining techniques used by individuals for Greek-style variations. On the other hand, commercial yogurts often include thickeners like pectin or gelatin that give them a more consistent texture but may not always be as smooth or enjoyable as their homemade counterparts.

Probiotics are an essential component of yogurt due to their potential health benefits for digestion and immune function. While both homemade and store-bought yogurts contain live cultures (probiotics), it's important to note that some commercial brands heat-treat their products after fermentation which decreases probiotic levels significantly.

When making your own yogurt at home using specific strains of bacteria cultures or even incorporating probiotic supplements into the process, you have full control over the potency and variety of beneficial bacteria present. In terms of cost, homemade yogurt is undeniably more economical.

While initial investments may be required for equipment such as a yogurt maker or high-quality starter cultures, these expenses are a one-time investment that can save money in the long run. Purchasing store-bought yogurts regularly can quickly add up, especially when buying premium brands or specialty varieties.

Both homemade and store-bought yogurts have their merits. Homemade yogurt allows for customization, better control over ingredients and potentially higher probiotic content.

It also offers the opportunity to experiment with flavors and achieve a creamier texture. On the other hand, store-bought yogurts provide convenience and a wide range of options but often come at the expense of added sugars, artificial flavors, and reduced probiotic levels.

Ultimately, choosing between homemade and store-bought yogurt depends on individual preferences regarding taste, health considerations, budget constraints, and available time for preparation. Regardless of your choice though, embracing yogurt as part of a balanced diet can contribute to a healthier lifestyle overall - so enjoy your cup of creamy goodness with confidence!